Would the real Jesus please stand up?

Are you old enough to remember the television show, To Tell the Truth? It was a game show where a description was given of an individual based on unusual experiences or occupation, then three people would appear before the contestants. The contestants could ask the three individuals questions to discover who the host described. The central character had to tell the truth when answering the questions, but the two imposters were able to lie. When it was time for the reveal, the host would say, Will the real [person's name] please stand up?" I couldn't help but think of that show [...]